Judge sentences Flint activist — Likens her actions to Dallas killings

Latest

Judge compares the role of defendant Gertrude Marshall (left) arrested in an altercation with security guards at a water protest as comparable to “what happened in Dallas” where five police officers were killed.
Judge compares the role of defendant Gertrude Marshall (left) arrested in an altercation with security guards at a water protest as comparable to “what happened in Dallas” where five police officers were killed.

Editor’s note: This article illustrates the dangerous political climate fighters, in this case for basic needs such as safe water, face in Michigan.
FLINT, MI — Gertrude Marshall was arrested in October, 2015, while protesting the water situation at the Flint Farmers Market. When one of the “security guards” snatched the bullhorn out of Ms. Marshall’s hand, an altercation ensued. Another “security guard” joined in and witnesses, along with Ms. Marshall, say that she was defending herself against physical brutality by the so-called guards. When the dust was cleared, she was charged with a misdemeanor, assault and battery, and attempted assault and battery.  Gertrude Marshall has maintained her innocence throughout this whole ordeal.
With “Sliced and diced” video evidence, the jury found her guilty. At the sentencing on July 8, Judge Cathy Doud shocked the courtroom when she accused Ms. Marshall of “making a fool of yourself” at the protest. She went on to compare her role in the incident to “what happened in Dallas,” where five Dallas police officers were killed. Judge Doud threw the book at defendant Marshall (just shy of jail time.) She got two years strict probation, community service, anger management classes, and hundreds of dollars in fines.  She is appealing her conviction.

+ Articles by this author

The People’s Tribune opens its pages to voices of the movement for change. Our articles are written by individuals or organizations, along with our own reporting. Bylined articles reflect the views of the authors. Articles entitled “From the Editors” reflect the views of the editorial board. Please credit the source when sharing: peoplestribune.orgPlease donate to help us keep bringing you voices of the movement for change. Click here. We’re all volunteer, no paid staff. The People’s Tribune is a 501C4 organization.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Featured

ICE Raids Mean the Return of Brutal Family Separations

The separation of immigrant families at the border was barred by the 2023 settlement of a lawsuit, but the Trump administration has found a way to brutally reimpose family separations, by moving the practice away from the border and doing it through the ongoing ICE raids.

A Turning Point Worth Celebrating — The Night Voters Said Enough

The November, 2025 election was a win for the workers, renters, the forgotten, and dreamers. It wasn't just about beating the far-right. It was also about rejecting the stale Democratic politics that too often bends to corporate donors and Wall Street.

Couple Seeks Accountability After Mom In Active Labor Discharged

A Black couple from Illinois was discharged from an Indiana hospital while the mother was in active labor, forcing a roadside birth.

Poverty and Deportees on the Streets in Tijuana

In U.S. media, even progressive media, we pay little attention to what happens to people when they're deported. Many are dumped through the border gate, have no home to go to and live on the streets in cities like Tijuana.

No Tows Without Homes

At the same time that advocates for San Francisco’s vehicle-dwelling residents charged the City to protect RV and large vehicle residents from displacement by a parking enforcement program, City workers were removing trailers about five miles away.

More from the People's Tribune