Homeless people not in need of a cell to get well

More News

Paul Soto speaks in December at rally in San Jose against Trump’s plan to round up homeless people in San Jose and 20 other cities across the country.
PHOTO/RONALD ORLANDO

Editor’s note: This testimony below was delivered at a hearing on so-called “Laura’s Law,” forced treatment and conservatorship for homeless people, to California’s Santa Clara County Board of Supervisors in December 2019.
SAN JOSE, CA — Members of the Council and my fellow citizens, in the spirit of the ancient Greek forums of old, when men of reason, logic, and a sense of civic duty gathered to bear witness to the affairs that impact the body politic, it is with great humility that I present my contention.
Human compassion, moral conviction, and ethical concerns compel me to challenge the well-intentioned, politically expedient, yet ignorant assertion that homeless people should be conserved and incarcerated.
Human beings are not broken parts in a machine. We are endowed by our Creator with certain inalienable rights. Amongst these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness; and to secure these rights, governments were instituted to provide for the common welfare.
My homeboys and homegirls living outside along the Guadalupe River are not in need of a cell to get well, they are in need of spiritual physicians to heal their human conditions.
Can you realize the law has no place when a human needs shelter? Yesterday’s Martin v. Boise decision by the Supreme Court permitted the lower court ruling to stand that a human being has a right to erect a shelter in any public sidewalk or park, if the City or County fails to provide housing. Is not this a vindication of the idea that the law has no place if no shelter exists?
As a society, in order to have social justice we must first practice economic justice. The notion that pointing a gun at a citizen ordering him to put his hands behind his back because he is experiencing the abject consequences of poverty, generational trauma, PTSD, or schizophrenia is insane.
Members of the Council, I appeal to your sense of humanity, which should be the ethical guide in the legislation of laws that impact men’s lives. We are at a precipice. Your decisions will impact the lives of not only the least of these, but will reflect on us as a community, baring our impotency in dealing ethically, morally, and compassionately with our fellow citizens.”

+ Articles by this author

The People’s Tribune opens its pages to voices of the movement for change. Our articles are written by individuals or organizations, along with our own reporting. Bylined articles reflect the views of the authors. Articles entitled “From the Editors” reflect the views of the editorial board. Please credit the source when sharing: peoplestribune.org. Please donate to help us keep bringing you voices of the movement for change. Click here. We’re all volunteer, no paid staff. The People’s Tribune is a 501C4 organization.

Featured

Appalachia and the South Have Something to Say. It’s Time We Started Listening.

The recent election results should remind anyone paying attention that these regions, Appalachia and the South, are neither politically irrelevant nor willing to sit quietly while others decide their future.

Before the Border Wall: The Last Stand at Lochiel

This video by the Border Chronicle’s Erin Patrick O’Connor captures the protest movement that grew this year in southern Arizona in an effort to stop border wall construction.

Over a Million Seniors Scrambling as Medicare Advantage Giants Slash Plans Under Trump

Seniors are scrambling to find alternative health coverage as Humana, UnitedHealthcare, and other private insurance giants slash Medicare Advantage benefits and cancel some plans entirely, despite big pay boost from Trump.

Listen to the New Song ‘Billionaires’

Billionaires, a song by singer and song writer Chris Buhalis, who says, "I am not on this planet to serve billionaire overlords—and neither are you. Bilionaires are not your fucking friends."

Time to Dream Big and Deliver Big

The midterm elections have dramatically demonstrated what most voters want for a new and vibrant political and economic landscape: How to live and work healthily and strongly without paying through our noses.

More from the People's Tribune