Youth Bring Historic Climate Lawsuit Against State of Montana

Plaintiffs Argue Support for Fossil fuels is Unconstitutional, robbed them of healthy environment

Latest

Youth plaintiffs in Held v. Montana testified that the state violated their constitutional right to a clean and healthful environment. VIDEO STILL / PBS

The first-ever constitutional climate trial in the U.S. — the result of 16 youths suing the Montana government for promoting and supporting fossil fuels that dangerously warm up the planet — concluded June 23. A ruling was expected in several weeks. There are similar suits in all 50 states.

The Montana Constitution, amended in 1972, declares that “the state and each person shall maintain and improve a clean and healthful environment in Montana for present and future generations,” and “all persons are born free and have certain inalienable rights,” including “the right to a clean and healthful environment.” These revisions were made at a constitutional convention to reduce the influence of the copper and coal industries, big players in Montana politics since the 1880s.

The plaintiffs argued Montana’s extensive support for fossil fuels is unconstitutional because the resulting pollution is dangerously heating the planet and has robbed them of a healthy environment.

Grace, one of the 16 youths behind Held v. State of Montana, stated, “Going to trial means a chance for me and my fellow plaintiffs to have our climate injuries recognized and a solution realized. It means our voices are actually being heard by the courts, the government, the people who serve to protect us as citizens, and Montana’s youth.”

Kian T., 18, described trying to play soccer outdoors in excessive heat. “I have had many, many soccer practices canceled for smoke and heat. Playing soccer on turf in the heat is miserable. Imagine your feet are boiling in your cleats, burning every single step you take on the field. It burns you out.”

“We’re really trying to bring the youth generation to the courts, and do so through a human rights lens,” said Julia Olson, founder of Our Children’s Trust, the lead attorney. Olson, along with her team, are also helping 21 young Americans challenge the constitutionality of federal government policies that promote fossil fuel production and consumption in the case of Juliana v. the United States. For eight years, the U.S. Department of Justice under the last three presidents have used legal maneuvers to keep the case from going to court. Recently a federal judge has ruled the lawsuit can proceed. The youth plaintiffs in the Montana case hope their suit will help set a precedent for this and other legal challenges to the fossil fuel industries.

While the Montana lawsuit is the first of its kind in U.S. history, it must not be the last. And because greenhouse gases don’t stop at state boundaries, litigation should not be limited to state energy policies. The U.S. government and governments worldwide need to fulfill their obligation to fundamental human rights by ending fossil fuel pollution.

Our children deserve credit and all the support we can give them for trying to hold governments accountable.

The information for this article is from a series of articles in the Climate Emergency News Section of Common Dreams at commondreams.org.

+ Articles by this author

Cathy Talbott is a former telephone operator, a job lost to automation. She was a homeless mother of two and fights for welfare rights.  A former co-host of a weekly community radio program out of Carbondale, IL, “Occupy the Airwaves,” Cathy is the Environmental Desk for the People’s Tribune.

Free to republish but please credit the People's Tribune. Visit us at www.peoplestribune.org, email peoplestribune@gmail.com, or call 773-486-3551.

The People’s Tribune brings you articles written by individuals or organizations, along with our own reporting. Bylined articles reflect the views of the authors. Unsigned articles reflect the views of the editorial board. Please credit the source when sharing: ©2024 peoplestribune.org. Please donate to help us keep bringing you voices of the movement. Click here. We’re all volunteer, no paid staff.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Featured

Pregnant Teen Died: Seeks Care in Three Texas Emergency Rooms

Nevaeh Crain cried in pain, too weak to walk, blood staining her thighs. Vomiting and feverish at her baby shower, the teen went to two different emergency rooms, returning home, worse than before. Pregnant women have become untouchables.

No, Immigration Is Not Making Housing Less Affordable

Despite politicians' claims to the contrary, immigration is not making housing unaffordable. In fact, immigration can be part of the solution.

Make Your Vote Count 

This 2024 election is gaining on us and the pressure to get to the ballot box is intense and...

Michigan’s Prescient Lesson: Vote While You Still Can!!! 

Michigan's non-elected Emergency Manager dictatorship made Flint's water crisis possible. Pay attention to the danger of losing our Democratic rights as we’ve known them in this election. Vote while you still can!

US Doctors Tell Biden, Harris They ‘Witnessed Crimes Beyond Comprehension’ in Gaza

US doctors who visited Gaza tell Biden, Harris they've never seen such horrific injuries, on such a massive scale, with so few resources, that our bombs are cutting down women and children, and that a ceasefire must be imposed.

More from the People's Tribune