The Economy: ‘It’s the Best of Times, it’s the Worst of Times’ 

Stock Market Soars While Workers Go Hungry

Latest

Giant robot throwing man in a trash can. Artifical intelligence replacing jobs concept. feature photo for cathy's economy article
Photo/iStock

What’s going on with the economy?  

The pundits all over the news tell us the market is booming. Even Trump’s recently fired Attorney General, Pam Bondi, screamed the Dow was at 50,000 as she was grilled by a congressional committee looking into the Epstein scandals. Everyone from the president to Wall Street analysts to status quo economists to congressional representatives laud the remarkable rise of the market! To this class of individuals, “the stock market” is the economy. And AI is the reason the stock market is booming. The only reason. 

But most of us do not own stocks. We make our living working for wages. Many of us work two and even three jobs. Yet it is becoming increasingly difficult to make ends meet! The only markets we’re concerned with are the labor market and the market where we buy our necessities that we need to survive. These markets represent another economy: the economy of producing, selling, and distributing our daily bread. And this economy isn’t doing well for us at all! (Energy costs rose by 10.9 percent last month, the price of fuel oil spiked by 30.7 percent, the cost of gasoline by 21.2 percent and energy commodities by 21.3 percent, according to the BLS data. ) 

photo for cathy's economy article
The upper line on the chart shows the rise in the S&P 500 index since 2021, while the lower line shows the hiring rate over this period. Source: still from Max Fisher video on YouTube

The March jobs report dropped on Good Friday. The pundits applauded the 4.3% unemployment (down from 4.4% in February) and the 178,000 jobs created. We are told that even with rising prices, everything is great! Fantastic! Better than it’s ever been! So why are millions of us struggling to put food on the table, put gas in our vehicles, and pay the electric bill? Even with the increase in wages (wages have increased 42.4% since the 2008 recession), our paychecks can’t keep up. We must be doing something wrong if the pundits are right. Are we crazy? 

Well, we are not crazy. Let’s peel back some layers of this report and get to the heart of the matter. First, 76,000 of those 178,000 jobs were in healthcare, and 31,000 of those were healthcare workers that had been on strike and returned to work. That makes only 45,000 jobs created in healthcare. There were 21,000 jobs added in transportation, 26,000 in construction, 14,000 in the social sector, and a negative 18,000 in government employment. The government is the largest employer. Because of Musk and DOGE, the government lost 355,000 jobs in 17 months, down 11.8%. There were 64,000 fewer jobs in March. 

So how did the unemployment rate drop by 1% in March? This is the little-known secret the government doesn’t share openly. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) there were from 468,000 to 510,000 discouraged workers in the US who are not in the labor force, want a job, and are available to work but stopped searching because they believe no jobs are available. These workers are not included in the official unemployment rate. There are currently 6 million people that are not counted in the labor force who say they want a job.  

So now we have millions of workers who want to work but can’t find a job, and we have employers who apparently are not hiring workers. If the economy, according to the experts, is doing so well (Just look at the DOW!), why aren’t jobs increasing? Why is our government cutting all the programs that aid us workers and our families so we can work? After all, isn’t it the workers who keep an economy going? Who makes the stuff we need to live and who buys that stuff? Historically, in an expanding economy, it has been us workers who have kept the system going. Without us there were no goods and services produced for the owners to sell back to us, which grew their profits! So why are there no jobs? 

Well, who are the producers in our booming economy today?  

Today workers are being replaced by automation in increasing numbers. Motivated by the oil shock which raises the risk of global recession and depression, 66% of CEOs plan to freeze or cut hiring through 2026. These business leaders are betting on AI to do the job. But wait! If you think you’ll get a job in AI, there were 80,000 layoffs in high tech in the first quarter of 2026, and nearly 50% of those were due to AI replacing workers! AI led all reasons for job cuts in March. 

So, if AI is the basis for the new economy, but there will not be an expansion in employment, what is to be done? If everything we need to survive is produced by robots who don’t eat or buy what’s produced, and our political class is destroying our means of survival by transferring all the wealth up to the owning class, then we need to organize like never before to get what we need to survive and thrive. We can’t continue to allow Wall Street to dominate the economy. We must not allow the pundits to divide us. It is not immigrants stealing our jobs. None of us own the jobs. We don’t own the economy.  

We need a different economy; one that works for us. It’s plain to see that the current owners will discard us like yesterday’s bad news if we no longer serve their interests. With AI, most of us are no longer necessary in its society. History is giving us a choice: organize to get what we need or die! 

+ Articles by this author

Cathy Talbott is a former telephone operator, a job lost to automation. She was a homeless mother of two and fights for welfare rights.  A former co-host of a weekly community radio program out of Carbondale, IL, “Occupy the Airwaves,” Cathy is the Environmental Desk for the People’s Tribune.

The People’s Tribune opens its pages to voices of the movement for change. Our articles are written by individuals or organizations, along with our own reporting. Bylined articles reflect the views of the authors. Articles entitled “From the Editors” reflect the views of the editorial board. Please credit the source when sharing: peoplestribune.org. Please donate to help us keep bringing you voices of the movement for change. Click here. We’re all volunteer, no paid staff. The People’s Tribune is a 501C4 organization.

Featured

Trump Sent Homeland Security to Search My House

"In their ludicrous, partisan investigation into my immigration status, Trump is telling his voters: Ignore the price of gas, the war in Iran, that you’re losing healthcare —get angry about this instead," says U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar.

Abolish ICE: Protests Erupt in NYC After ICE Shoots Father With Son in Car

"There is no excuse for allowing ICE to come into our city, to shoot seven bullets into cars where there are children. It is just an outrage. I truly have no words for just how enraging everything that transpired last night was," says candidate for Congress in New York City.

We are Jane Doe

What happens when the institution responsible for investigating harm is the same institution worried about its reputation, donors, fraternity relationships, and legal liability? Silence protects power. Accountability means confronting it.

Nancy Leaves Before Dawn

This story brings insight into the lives of the millions of women and men who leave before dawn to keep entire cities running by cleaning, building, cooking, caring. But suddenly some want them seen them as criminals.

Government Charges Man ICE Shot In Back With Assault

Wilber Rafael Garces Perez, the Venezuelan immigrant shot in the back by an ICE agent in Austin September 20, has now been charged by the government with assaulting a federal officer.

More from the People's Tribune