Four Listings, Zero Homes

More News

Protester at the Federal Building in San Francisco City demands House the People/Photo by Sarah Menefee
Protester at the Federal Building in San Francisco City demands House the People/Photo by Sarah Menefee

I’m 65, and I receive $1,269 a month in Social Security and SSI. Using the common 30% housing-cost benchmark, that leaves $380.70 a month for housing, including utilities. That figure is a yardstick, not a rent rule for every subsidized apartment. But it shows the scale of the problem: a $788 room would take about 62% of my income and leave $481 for everything else.

I have looked at four senior-housing options: Hawthorn Senior Apartments, Laurel I & II at Perennial Park, Silvercrest Senior Living Residence, and Casa Grande. A listing can look like an opening. It does not tell me whether I can meet the income requirement, whether a waitlist is moving, or whether the rent fits a fixed monthly check.

Tne answer is documented. Burbank Housing’s September 25 notice removed me from Laurel I & II because my annual income was below its stated $27,744 minimum. My reported Social Security and SSI total $15,228 a year—a gap of $12,516. Burbank upheld the decision on October 6 and referred me to the City of Santa Rosa’s Project-Based Voucher waiting list. That referral may be a route to explore; it is not a home or a move-in date.

At Silvercrest, I was told by phone that I needed about twice my current income. I have not received written confirmation of that requirement. The status and terms for the other options also need to be checked. I’m not claiming that four providers made four identical decisions. I’m describing what a person can see from the applicant’s side: four listings, and no confirmed home I can afford.

The statewide picture is larger than my search. A California Department of Aging analysis found that about half of renter households with an older adult or a person with a disability spend more than 30% of income on housing. Among extremely low-income households in those groups, about 80% do. The report combines older-adult and disability households; it does not say those percentages apply to seniors alone.

I understand economics and marketing. Money is a tool; it does not choose where to flow. People and the systems they build direct it. A housing market can produce apartments, waiting lists, flyers, and referrals while still leaving the lowest-income seniors without a door they can open. A spreadsheet may count four opportunities. My life still needs one home.

I am in transitional housing now, but a temporary room is not permanent retirement security. I want housing whose real cost fits a fixed income, and a clear path from an application to an actual unit. If a program is called affordable, applicants should be able to see the rent, utility assumptions, income rules, subsidy, and next step in plain language.

Dear Jesus, help someone open a door. Then help me hold it for the next woman. She’s probably already got the referrals, too.

Sources: California Department of Aging, California Statewide Non-Medi-Cal Home and Community-Based Services Gap Analysis Report (housing-cost burden findings); California Department of Housing and Community Development, “Overpaying.” Personal application and income details are Renee’s account; the September 25 Burbank notice documents the stated minimum-income reason. The Silvercrest statement is reported from a phone conversation and has not been confirmed in writing.

California Department of Aging report

California HCD cost-burden guidance

+ Articles by this author

Renee Belinda Cooper, M.B.A., has a background in economics and self-employment. After more than 11 months of homelessness, she is becoming a columnist to fight for humanity in a system that offers a runaround instead of a roof.

The People’s Tribune opens its pages to voices of the movement for change. Our articles are written by individuals or organizations, along with our own reporting. Bylined articles reflect the views of the authors. Articles entitled “From the Editors” reflect the views of the editorial board. Please credit the source when sharing: peoplestribune.org. Please donate to help us keep bringing you voices of the movement for change. Click here. We’re all volunteer, no paid staff. The People’s Tribune is a 501C4 organization.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Featured

Over a Million Seniors Scrambling as Medicare Advantage Giants Slash Plans Under Trump

Seniors are scrambling to find alternative health coverage as Humana, UnitedHealthcare, and other private insurance giants slash Medicare Advantage benefits and cancel some plans entirely, despite big pay boost from Trump.

Listen to the New Song ‘Billionaires’

Billionaires, a song by singer and song writer Chris Buhalis, who says, "I am not on this planet to serve billionaire overlords—and neither are you. Bilionaires are not your fucking friends."

Time to Dream Big and Deliver Big

The midterm elections have dramatically demonstrated what most voters want for a new and vibrant political and economic landscape: How to live and work healthily and strongly without paying through our noses.

Elections: The People Have Spoken Loud and Clear

The midterm election victories were not so much an endorsement of the Democrats as a social revolt against the ongoing assault on the people. The people demanded that their voices be heard and their needs be addressed. There will no doubt be more upheavals to come.

Michigan Senate Race Could Signal Game Changer in Electoral Politics

The world is watching Abdul El-Sayed, candidate for U.S. Senate race in Michigan.

More from the People's Tribune