‘Unhoused Neighbors’ Film Review

Latest

An unhoused neighbor in San Francisco in danger of losing their only shelter /Photo by Sarah Menefee
An unhoused neighbor in San Francisco in danger of losing their only shelter /Photo by Sarah Menefee

The film “Unhoused Neighbors,” shot in Sacramento between the Spring of 2024 and the Winter of 2025, is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.

The Introduction to the film “Unhoused Neighbors” asks us to consider “what it means” to live in extreme poverty in America’s wealthiest state. At the close of the film, on a black screen, the numbers scroll: upwards of 770,000 people unhoused in the U.S.

“These are just seven of them,” the final sentence reads.

It’s a quiet film. Seven unhoused people face the camera, unguarded, and speak in low voices, explaining the arc of their lives, so far. Months, even years, of living outside. The faces often thoughtful, reflective, somber, curiously free of anger, but also confident, optimistic.

The film is shot in Sacramento, mostly downtown in Alkali Flat. Not the trees, not the century-old houses and leafy back yards. No. The streets stretch out into the distance, hard surfaced, nearly deserted, enclosing these seven people with silence, heat, rain – by the roadside or in the empty lot, perched on a tailgate, camped under a freeway overpass. A shot of a campsite left devastated by a fire and a police raid. Everything needed – gone.

An image of two pigeons nestling against the girders of a railroad trestle across the Sacramento River somehow captures the fragility of belonging to the surrounding city.

Alicia, “street homeless” for 5 years, and Lauren, who lives in her car, cast out of her profession by the pandemic, are the first two to be introduced. Each of them, in different, even contrasting, ways, reflects on how their destinies are caught up with family.

In the midst of her struggle with mental health and addiction, Alicia gave up the baby she birthed at 21, placing her with people who could afford to send her to college. “’I’m not going to be the person, later, who stands in the way of her full potential,” Alicia tells us as she grieves the loss, and explains, too, how being a mother sustains her. “The only reason I’m alive is because of her.”

The film takes us out on the delta with Alicia at the wheel. “Freedom,” she says, “that’s the biggest emotion I feel when I’m driving. We were never in one place for too long – one to three months at the most. So to be driving, I get that feeling of freedom and hope. For me, home is, like, the road. That’s why I want to drive for a career.”

Lauren, dealing with the “logistical realities of being a transgender person,” has been “disowned” by her family, who stopped supporting her “in every possible way.” Still, she attends to small goals, though it might seem silly, she says, like cleaning out her living space, making her bed. Every night she parks on a different street, and, in secret, folds her body into her Prius to sleep.

Jordan, who grew up on a small farm, explains that he was exposed, after high school, to “the party life style.” In his teens and twenties – even as he trained to be an airplane pilot – he got hooked on opioids. “It takes over your life. Everything you do has to revolve around that. You build up physical dependency. You get sick. It sucks. It’s tough.” Now in his thirties, facing jail for a commercial burglary conviction, he refuses to give up on himself. “I have a lot of potential,” he says, “I want to get on with my life.”

We see him leaving his tent at 1 am and, using a headlamp, carefully sift through garbage cans in front of big houses. “We have to beat the trash truck.” Recycling from a neighborhood where they hold parties and barbecues, “It’s clean. Nice for it to be clean and not smell too bad. We like to leave it cleaner than we find it.”

Danny, a Navy veteran and law graduate, slips into homelessness after he suffers a brain injury. He’s shot in the head by the police while serving as a legal observer during the George Floyd uprising. Losing his job and then his housing, he moves into a neighborhood “Safe Ground” camp that has an exemption from police sweeps. He’s caring for his “elder dog.” Knows it is their last year together. We see grizzled “Gonzo,” who suffers from a heart condition, slowly padding after Danny. “It’s 105 degrees outside. Just doing your best to take care of him. It’s hard.”

The camera moves to an overhead shot of the city and its somber night streets, tents under a freeway overpass. It could be anywhere.

Carl, a vet, tells us he is 62 years old. “The army is the only place I felt I really belonged.” He came back to Sacramento to care for his mother, and lost his housing when his step dad signed off on a reverse mortgage and he lost any inheritance. He has lived outside for 7 years, making his own tents with canvas and heavy tarps to face weather that is “brutal.” We see him cooking on a propane stove, laying bread slices on a meticulously clean paper towel. “There’s a lot of people with big hearts who come around, bring you meals, bring you clothing. People are people no matter where you’re at.” He’s making sandwiches for his neighbors.”

The camera finds Tammy sitting on a wall. “Going to smoke another cigarette,” she says. “I don’t give people my last stuff, I won’t put myself out, but if I have extra stuff, I always share. I don’t need a profit from it, I don’t need money for it.” Tammy says she skate boards all over the place. “That’s what got me through everything. Skate boarding and music got me through the best and worst life has to offer.”

We spend a few minutes with Howard, who’s in mourning for his wife and close family, wondering why the Lord has sent him such loss. Howard has passed away. “He was a really good man,” Tammy tells us. “A lot of people are affected by his death.” Howard was Tammy’s best friend.

Tammy is bottle feeding kittens with a Narcan syringe dropped off by a local harm reduction service. She finds an abandoned apartment and stays there, awaiting eviction, pointing out that the rent, which she does not pay, is “crazy” at $2,000 per month. One of the kittens – everyone’s favorite – is hit by a car. “He was named Howard, in memory of my friend,” Tammy says.

The introduction to the film asks us to consider what it means to live in extreme poverty. Wanting to understand the question, I looked up the root of the word “‘meaning”’ — in Sanscrit, the root word is ‘artha,’ referring to the concepts of “purpose” or “significance.” So what is the “purpose” or “significance” of this glimpse into the lives of these seven people?

The film answers the question. These lives are not defined by homelessness, these seven individuals are not defined by extreme poverty. They are defined – illuminated, even – by resilience, struggle, generosity. Just like the rest of us. Here walks no separate tribe, no ragged alien pack. Deeply individual, the integrity of each of these seven people shines through their day-to-day striving and their care for their neighbors, their comrades in homelessness, their beloved and vulnerable animals. They have little: their lives, as intense and connected, as sad, joyful, and memorable, as anyone’s life may be.

 

 

 

 

+ Articles by this author
Cathleen Williams is an organizer, poet, and journalist for street newspapers. She
lives in Sacramento, California, and is active in the Sacramento Poor People’s Campaign and the League of Revolutionaries for a new America.

The People’s Tribune opens its pages to voices of the movement for change. Our articles are written by individuals or organizations, along with our own reporting. Bylined articles reflect the views of the authors. Articles entitled “From the Editors” reflect the views of the editorial board. Please credit the source when sharing: peoplestribune.org. Please donate to help us keep bringing you voices of the movement for change. Click here. We’re all volunteer, no paid staff. The People’s Tribune is a 501C4 organization.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Featured

Government Charges Man ICE Shot In Back With Assault

In the case of Wilber Rafael Garces Perez, the Venezuelan immigrant who was shot in the back by an ICE agent in Austin September 20, the government has now charged him with assaulting a federal officer. He is still being denied the surgery he needs to remove a bullet from his body.

People Keep Dying in ICE Custody. 13 Dems Back a Bill to Abolish the Agency

Legislation has been introduced called the Melt ICE Act which would dismantle ICE by ending the Department of Homeland Security’s authority to surveil and jail immigrants and redirect its funding to navigate a spiraling affordability crisis.

Resistance is Challenging Grip of AIPAC on Congress

The pro-Israel AIPAC lobby is one of the most powerful lobbies in the country, but its influence over our elections and Congress is increasingly being challenged by candidates and voters.

Angie Nixon, Senate Candidate for Florida, Resolves Capitol Protest Case

Florida US Senate candidate Angie Dixon is no longer facing a prison sentence, having resolving resolved the case brought against her by Florida authorities, after she was arrested for trying to meet with Florida's governor about their redistricting plan.

ICE Shooting of Austin Delivery Man Sparks Outrage

Austin shooting came 10 weeks after ICE agent fatally shot Lorenzo Salgado Araujo in Houston, whch followed a series of shootings involving ICE, including the killing of US citizens Renée Good and Alex Pretti in MN. Austin community protests arose immediately with renewed calls to Abolish ICE.

More from the People's Tribune